Heritage Foundation
·
Published
January 30, 2025
Share this article

Summary

President Trump's questioning of the birthright citizenship clause is based on a historical interpretation of the 14th Amendment. This perspective suggests that citizenship was never intended for all individuals born in the U.S. without consideration of parental status, per commentary from Heritage Foundation.

President Trump's questioning of the birthright citizenship clause is based on a historical interpretation of the 14th Amendment. This perspective suggests that citizenship was never intended for all individuals born in the U.S. without consideration of parental status, per commentary from Heritage Foundation.

The issue:  

The core challenge revolves around the interpretation of the 14th Amendment, which states that only those born "subject to the jurisdiction" of the U.S. are citizens. Historical context indicates that the amendment was designed to eliminate race-based citizenship barriers rather than to guarantee citizenship for all born in the U.S.

Go deeper:  

Legislative history underscores that children born to non-citizens owe allegiance to their parents' home countries, thereby precluding automatic U.S. citizenship. Iconic court cases like Elk v. Wilkins (1884) reinforce the view that the Supreme Court has historically limited the scope of birthright citizenship. The president's order seeks to realign federal policy to adhere to this original intent of the 14th Amendment.

This is a brief overview of a commentary from Heritage Foundation. For complete insights, we recommend reading the full commentary.

Related articles

All Topics
All Topics
All Topics
All Topics
All Topics
All Topics
All Topics
All Topics
All Topics
All Topics
All Topics
All Topics
All Topics
All Topics
All Topics
All Topics
All Topics
All Topics
All Topics
All Topics
All Topics
Denial Without Disaster—Keeping a U.S.-China Conflict over Taiwan Under the Nuclear Threshold
RAND Corporation
·
Nov 18, 2023

Denial Without Disaster—Keeping a U.S.-China Conflict over Taiwan Under the Nuclear Threshold

Summary

The U.S. must navigate the complexities of a potential Taiwan conflict concerning China while preventing nuclear escalation. The evolving nature of China's nuclear capabilities demands a more nuanced approach from the U.S. military, especially regarding its operational strategies, per commentary from RAND Corporation.

Center
Report
·
U.S.-China Relations
Read summary
(1 min.)
-->
Gender Wars Are an Early Warning Sign for Authoritarianism
RAND Corporation
·
Nov 18, 2023

Gender Wars Are an Early Warning Sign for Authoritarianism

Summary

Gender wars highlight the rise of authoritarianism globally, as seen in Georgia's struggle for democracy against Russian influence. Women leaders across various nations are pivotal in resisting these trends, emphasizing their essential role in safeguarding freedoms and rights, per commentary from RAND Corporation.  

Center
Commentary
·
U.S. Politics
Read summary
(1 min.)
-->
Can the world trading system survive Donald Trump?
Peterson Institute for International Economics
·
Nov 18, 2023

Can the world trading system survive Donald Trump?

Summary

The world trading system faces significant challenges due to proposed tariffs by the U.S. president, notably a 60% tariff on China. These actions threaten to disrupt global trade and create tensions among member nations, as they debate their responses to this situation, per commentary from Peterson Institute for International Economics. 

Center
Speech
·
2024 U.S. Elections
Read summary
(1 min.)
-->
How to Succeed in Deterring an Invasion of Taiwan Without Really Trying (Hard)
RAND Corporation
·
Nov 18, 2023

How to Succeed in Deterring an Invasion of Taiwan Without Really Trying (Hard)

Summary

The potential for a Chinese invasion of Taiwan poses a significant challenge to U.S. national security. A successful invasion would not only oppress the Taiwanese people but also expand China's influence across East Asia, threatening regional stability, per commentary from RAND Corporation.  

Center
Commentary
·
U.S.-China Relations
Read summary
(1 min.)
-->
Syria’s challenges are even greater than those Libya faced in 2011
Chatham House
·
Nov 18, 2023

Syria’s challenges are even greater than those Libya faced in 2011

Summary

Syria faces more daunting challenges than Libya did in 2011, highlighted by deep social divisions, a devastated infrastructure, and a complex geopolitical landscape. The situation calls for cautious optimism as Syrians navigate a new political reality following the fall of the Assad regime, per commentary from Chatham House.

Nonpartisan
Commentary
·
International Affairs
Read summary
(1 min.)
-->
No results found.
Original Read Time
9 min
Organization
The Brookings Institution
Category
Israel-Gaza War
Political Ideology
Center Left

We make expert analysis of current events
simple and accessible for all.

Join us in elevating our public discourse.